Topic Options
#1462591 - 26/04/2018 14:18 FV3-GFS
ashestoashes Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 22/10/2017
Posts: 467
Loc: Voyager Point (South West Sydn...
Hi all,
I noticed on tropical tidbits that they had the new experimental FV3-GFS model available although for only the US. I was wondering when it will become operational on our side of the planet, also how it will change the game in respect to weather modelling. Because from some research I saw that it can create resolutions of as high as 2km, but it counters it by dropping the resolution in other areas.

Top
#1463480 - 09/05/2018 21:59 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Flowin Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 15/10/2017
Posts: 545
Loc: Pinjarra Hills, Qld
A2A, I don't think Fv3-GFS is operational anywhere yet, but happy to be corrected.
Some experimental outputs are available for our region but only viewable at global scale.
http://data1.gfdl.noaa.gov/fvGFS/fvGFS_p...ow_slp_wind_6hr
I occasionally look at this for the total water path output.
Double check what the options are when using this site.

Top
#1465391 - 11/06/2018 06:55 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Flowin Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 15/10/2017
Posts: 545
Loc: Pinjarra Hills, Qld
I found this website where it is possible to view FV3-GFS experimental forecasts for Australia.
https://lab.weathermodels.com/models/gfs/fv3gfs.php

Top
#1465392 - 11/06/2018 08:11 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
retired weather man Offline
Weatherzone Addict

Registered: 01/07/2007
Posts: 4790
Loc: Wynnum
Thanks Flowin.
_________________________

Wyn Nth 2018-Jan12.2(158),Feb264.4(146),Mar217.0(126),Apr65.8(96),May46.0(100),Jun39.8(74),Jul19.6(56.1),Aug 23.6(45),Sep33.2(32),Oct150.0(95)Nov16.8(109)YTD888.4(1037.4),

Top
#1465398 - 11/06/2018 09:10 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
ashestoashes Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 22/10/2017
Posts: 467
Loc: Voyager Point (South West Sydn...
Thanks mate.

Top
#1465400 - 11/06/2018 10:16 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
ozone doug Offline
Weatherzone Addict

Registered: 06/11/2006
Posts: 1873
Loc: Roma SW QLD Eye to the West...
That,s great Flowin. I have book marked it.
_________________________
Cheers Doug. 491 Doug/ uhf ch40 When severe weather
BOM Stormspotter G0388 Roma S W Queensland Formerly Redcliffe.
https://www.wunderground.com/personal-weather-station/dashboard?ID=IQUEENSL852

Top
#1469661 - 28/08/2018 18:56 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Ken Kato Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 05/03/2012
Posts: 5471
I only just stumbled across this thread so thought I might throw my two cents worth in.

The FV3 (or more broadly, the name of the dynamical core of a bunch of models, one of which is due to replace the existing version of GFS later next year) is still technically in experimental stage so it's not operational yet.

It's been providing data for the whole globe for awhile now but there's only a few websites I know of that offer forecasts that cover our area and even then, it's usually restricted to a limited range of forecast products.

I've recently written some scripts to display realtime FV3 data for our region - see example below. One of its advantages over GFS is that it greatly reduces the often unrealistically intense rainfall bullseyes in convective setups that's plagued GFS for years.
Also, objective skill score stats for FV3 during its testing shows that it's performed significantly better than the current GFS (on average) in most parameters and regions including hurricane tracks and intensities although still not as good as EC and UK. Of course there'll always be some setups when another less skillful model or models will beat it.



Top
#1469758 - 30/08/2018 20:15 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Flowin Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 15/10/2017
Posts: 545
Loc: Pinjarra Hills, Qld
Thanks Ken,
That is a useful comparison. Your scripts to process the FV3 model outputs are good and would be helpful as while the FV3 is in the experimental / testing phase it is hard to get visualisation of it at meaningful scale for Australia.
I have been watching the precipitable water outputs of FV3 for a while and find the smaller resolution of FV3 more helpful to understand the likely moisture feed source and direction for some weather systems. I have an interest in this for atmospheric rivers which I have discussed in another thread.

Top
#1469761 - 30/08/2018 21:05 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Mega Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 03/02/2003
Posts: 7270
Loc: Maryborough, Wide Bay, QLD
You'd have to hope FV3-GFS does better than GFS in the tropics too because I've lost count how many typhoons it's bombed to ridiculous pressures this year (I'm talking as low as 900 hpa for some) while no other model suggests such a thing. It has been extremely bad in that respect and what's so embarrassing is all of those supposed upgrades to the model haven't seemed to have helped in that area at all.

Top
#1471909 - 03/10/2018 07:27 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Mega Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 03/02/2003
Posts: 7270
Loc: Maryborough, Wide Bay, QLD
Found this on Twitter, it shows the general timeline for the upgrade from GEFS (GFS Ensemble) to FV3GEFS through next year and into 2020:



All I can say is it's about bloody time.

Top
#1471910 - 03/10/2018 07:29 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Ken Kato Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 05/03/2012
Posts: 5471
You can also find the latest updates to that implementation timeline on the official website for the FV3 here: http://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/users/Alicia.Bentley/fv3gfs/

Top
#1471915 - 03/10/2018 08:12 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Flowin Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 15/10/2017
Posts: 545
Loc: Pinjarra Hills, Qld
Thanks for that link Ken. Some good information there.
I noted this presentation: http://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/users/Alicia.Bentley/fv3gfs/updates/MEG_9-27-18_FV3GFS_EVAL.pptx
Seems to suggest that FV3GFS may better than current GFS in relation to not overcooking cyclone intensity.
_________________________
Models are for estimating and gauges are for knowledge.

Top
#1474546 - 23/10/2018 20:51 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: Flowin]
Flowin Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 15/10/2017
Posts: 545
Loc: Pinjarra Hills, Qld
Originally Posted By: Flowin
I found this website where it is possible to view FV3-GFS experimental forecasts for Australia.
https://lab.weathermodels.com/models/gfs/fv3gfs.php

I discovered today that the link I posted earlier to FV3GFS is now not easily accessible.
If anybody knows where FV3GFS forecasts for Australia are available lets us know

Top
#1474547 - 23/10/2018 20:57 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Ken Kato Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 05/03/2012
Posts: 5471
That reminds me, Iíll post a skill score graph of FV3 vs other models tomorrow.
I was meaning to post it a few weeks ago but never got around to it.

Top
#1474568 - 24/10/2018 11:01 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Ken Kato Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 05/03/2012
Posts: 5471
The 1st image below is the skill scorecard for the current version of FV3 compared to the current GFS using the commonly used anomaly correlation technique. I probably wouldn't read too much into the MSLP comparison because MSLP scores can be quite erratic and often isn't the best representation of the overall skill of a model.

The 2nd image below is a skill score graph comparing FV3 to some other global models - it shows the die-off in skill of the models as a function of forecast lead time out to 10 days for runs averaged across the last 30 days (up to the 22nd Oct) for 850hpa winds in the southern hemisphere extratropics covering the latitudes between 20 and 80 degrees South. Note that the rainfall skill of overseas models isn't usually verified here in Australia until they've become fully operational for a sufficient period of time.

The higher the skill values (using anomaly correlation), the better.

Red = EC, orange = UK, purple = FV3, black = current GFS, blue = NAVGEM, JMA = grey, green = CMC, turquoise = CFSR.

The relative skill rankings of these models are generally similar across most regions, time of year, and weather parameters.

As you can see, there's been a big improvement in accuracy of the current version of FV3 over the current GFS. Even though it still isn't up there with the likes of EC, it looks promising so far.
I've been subjectively comparing FV3 forecasts with those from the current GFS for rainfall distribution and amounts in SE QLD/NE NSW for a little while now and from what I've noticed so far, the better skill of FV3 has been quite noticeable.
The fact that the FV3 almost eliminates unrealistically intense CAPE and rainfall bullseyes that have plagued the current version of GFS is also a bonus.

The FV3 doesn't seem to be as good for TC track forecasts outside of the Atlantic basin but that's just my subjective impression from some recent typhoons and eastern Pacific hurricanes so it could be wrong. As for inside the Atlantic basin, here's some skill graphs (red = FV3, green = GFS): http://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/emc.glopara/vsdb/prfv3rt1/www/track/track.html

But as always, there'll always be some individual cases when the FV3 will flop and other model/s will beat it... just like any model or forecast in general.
A person from the FV3 modelling team told me a few weeks ago that while they'll now try and keep the coding of the FV3 frozen until it becomes operational, they can't guarantee it until the code is officially frozen. So I hope they don't mess around with it too much (don't ruin a good thing) before it becomes operational unless they can make another substantial improvement in accuracy.








Edited by Ken Kato (24/10/2018 11:08)
Edit Reason: added stuff

Top
#1474570 - 24/10/2018 11:33 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
ashestoashes Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 22/10/2017
Posts: 467
Loc: Voyager Point (South West Sydn...
Ken on TC tracks FV3-GFS has the ability to alter the resolution over a region , with it being a US model it's very likely to focus on the Atlantic Basin. But come our TC season it's is very likely there will be improved resolution across the Indian Ocean and South Western Pacific, time will tell though.

Top
#1474572 - 24/10/2018 11:48 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Ken Kato Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 05/03/2012
Posts: 5471
ashestoashes: The subjective impression of non-Atlantic systems I was referring to was actually based on forecasts from the global FV3 that essentially had the same resolution for the western and eastern Pacific basins as the Atlantic basin (not a higher resolution nested version dedicated for the Atlantic basin).

Top
#1474587 - 24/10/2018 19:46 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Flowin Offline
Weather Freak

Registered: 15/10/2017
Posts: 545
Loc: Pinjarra Hills, Qld
Ken thanks for your input, much appreciated.
While forecasting is a skilled art, verifying is equally challenging.
I look forward to seeing FV3 becoming operational as I would like to see what it generates at a regional scale and whether it can get the location of rain more accurate (spatial displacement error reduced)

Top
#1475122 - 02/11/2018 14:25 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Mega Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 03/02/2003
Posts: 7270
Loc: Maryborough, Wide Bay, QLD
So, does anyone have a public link to FV3 yet since Weathermodels decided to paywall it?

Top
#1475143 - 02/11/2018 17:13 Re: FV3-GFS [Re: ashestoashes]
Mega Offline
Meteorological Motor Mouth

Registered: 03/02/2003
Posts: 7270
Loc: Maryborough, Wide Bay, QLD
Well, I found one...no precip and only 00z and 12z runs though: http://www.pivotalweather.com/model.php?m=gfs_fv3&p=sfcwind_mslp&rh=2018110200&fh=0&r=au&dpdt=

Top


Who's Online
0 registered (), 50 Guests and 2 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Today's Birthdays
beefy, falay002, Paul79, Ruckle
Forum Stats
29700 Members
32 Forums
24002 Topics
1502787 Posts

Max Online: 2925 @ 02/02/2011 22:23
Satellite Image